What Do Dairy Cows’ Y Chromosomes Have to Do with Young Earth Creationism? Plenty. – Patheos
Posted: October 25, 2019 at 1:48 am
Most U.S. Dairy Cows Are Descended from Just 2 Bulls. Thats Not Good, reads an NPR article. As I perused the article, it only took me a moment to make a connection to the young earth creationist teachings I was raised on.
A few years ago, Dechow and some of his colleagues at Penn State made a discovery that shocked a lot of people. All the Holstein bulls that farmers were using could trace their lineage back to one of just two male ancestors. Everything goes back to two bulls born in the 1950s and 1960s, he says. Their names were Round Oak Rag Apple Elevation and Pawnee Farm Arlinda Chief.
Or, to put it another way:
When researchers at the Pennsylvania State University looked closely at the male lines a few years ago,they discoveredmore than 99 percent of them can be traced back to one of two bulls, both born in the 1960s. That means among all the male Holsteins in the country, there are just two Y chromosomes.
There are just two Y chromosomes found among all Holstein dairy cows. Ponder that for a moment. And then consider this:According to young earth creationist doctrine, all humans after the flood could trace their lineage back to just one male ancestorNoah.
Think back to what you learned about genetics in high school. Most humans have either two X chromosomes or one X and one Y chromosome. Noah would have had one Y chromosome. His three sons would each have had the same Y chromosome. His grandchildren born after the Flood would also have had the same Y chromosome.Of course, there would have been only one Y chromosome to begin with anyway, hundreds of years before thisAdams.
Young earth creationists play fast and loose with genetics. Genetics does not work this way, and that its why researchers are worried about the U.S. dairy population.
What weve done is really narrowed down the genetic pool, saysChad Dechow, one of the researchers.
The females havent fared much better. In fact, Dechowan associate professor of dairy cattle geneticsand others say there is so much genetic similarity among them, the effective population size is less than 50. If Holsteins were wild animals, that would put them in the category of critically endangered species.
After the Flood, in young earth creationists telling, there was a human population size of 8. At creation, the human population size was 2. The level of inbreeding that would have to take place to end up with a population of millions (and, today, billions) starting with population sizes of 2 or 8 is mind numbing.
Theres a reason there are high rates of certain genetic defects among the Amish population.
Currently, more than 50,000 Lancaster County Amish can trace their lineage to just 80 ancestors
Fewer ancestors mean more sharing of genetic material and any genetic defects the same linked to potentially fatal hereditary diseases like SCID contained therein.
Meanwhile, genetic defects not found in the settler population remain locally non-existent.
This isthe founder effect, and evidence of it has been found in Amish and Mennonite populations from Pennsylvania and Ohio to Ontario, Canada.
The founder effect, population bottlenecksthese are real things that affect real, actual genetics. Again, you probably learned about these things in high school.
The thing about the founder effect and population bottlenecks is thatthey result in the loss of genetic information.That is simply how it works.
Any elementary science student knows that genetic homogeneity isnt good in the long term. It increases the risk of inherited disorders while also reducing the ability of a population to evolve in the face of a changing environment. Dairy farmers struggling to pay bills today arent necessarily focusing on the evolutionary prospects of their animals, but Dechow and his colleagues were concerned enough that they wanted to look more closely at what traits had been lost.
Young earth creationists typically respond to concerns about population bottlenecks in one of two ways. The either argue that the original couples genes contained far more genetic diversity than our genes today, effectively canceling the bottleneck entirely, or they argue that the genetic diversity we see today is the result of random mutations in DNA over time.
Lets take the first argument first. Genes simply do not work like that. A population can have more genetic diversity, but an individual person cant. A population of fifty adults living in Bozeman, Montana, for example, is going to have less genetic diversity than a group of fifty adults chosen at random from every country in the western hemisphere. But an individual adult in Bozeman is not going to have more genetic diversity than an individual adult in Brazil, Honduras, or Haiti. Genetics does not work like that.
Now, the second argumentthat the genetic diversity we see today is the result of mutations. Most scientists believe that all Y chromosomes that exist today can be traced back to one Y chromosome that existed around 150,000 years ago. In other words, all men living today have a common ancestor, sometimes termed Y-chromosomal Adam. Young earth creationists argue the same thing, but they put this ancestor only 4,000 years ago. And that matters!
Imagine the rate of mutation required to get all the Y chromosomes we have today, in only 4,000 years!Ive said it before and Im sure Ill say it again: young earth creationists are far stronger believers in evolution than any evolutionary scientist Ive ever met.
Ill leave you with one last thing, from an Answers in Genesis article titled The genetic effects of the population bottleneck associated with the Genesis Flood:
There is one other consideration to make before we conclude the discussion of created diversity, however: the introduction of mutations to the population prior to Babel. Mutational load in children increases with the age of the father (due to the fact that older men pass on gametes that have gone through many more generations/genome copying events than younger men). Thus, any child born to an ancient person could theoretically carry many genetic differences from other people. Extrapolating from the data of Crow, a man 500 years of age would donate approximately 10,000 mutations to a child (the current average is two orders of magnitude less than that). Konget al.concluded that every extra year of paternity adds an average of about 2 additional mutations. This would mean Noah would only contribute slightly more than 1,000 mutations (40 baseline mutations + 500 years x 2) after age 500. But they also discuss models with an exponential mutational increase over time and only studied men under age 50. Either way, it could be said that Noah, by far the oldest to have fathered children recorded in biblical history, was genetic poison to the future world population, as he would be expected to have contributed many new mutations to each of his three sons (and possibly his daughters-in-law, if they were daughters).
Yes. Yes, they really went there.Its ok that all humans are descended from one coupleNoah and his wifebecause Noah fathered his three sons when he was 500 years old, so they would have had lots and lots of mutations. Yep.
What was that I said about young earth creationists being stronger believers in evolution than any evolutionary scientist out there?
I guess that gives us a solution for the Holstein dairy cows, anywayresearchers should just breed them when theyre super old and their genetic diversity will come back. Because Im sure thats exactly what will happen. (It does not work like that.)
I have a Patreon! Please support my writing!
Read more here:
What Do Dairy Cows' Y Chromosomes Have to Do with Young Earth Creationism? Plenty. - Patheos
- 18,000-year-old puppy found remarkably preserved in permafrost - NBCNews.com - December 4th, 2019
- 10 ways of treating female hair loss - Medical News Today - December 4th, 2019
- Dog or wolf? Frozen 18,000-year-old puppy gives scientists pause - The Irish Times - December 4th, 2019
- Counseling the Stone Boys: Helping Boys and Men Who Have Been Sexually Abused - Psychotherapy.net - December 4th, 2019
- Amazon set a record of its own on Cyber Monday - Chain Store Age - December 4th, 2019
- Placenta Changes May Mean Male Babies Of Older Women Likely To Have Heart Problems - BabyGaga - December 4th, 2019
- Finding strength in the fight against muscular dystrophy - The News Record - December 4th, 2019
- 18000-year-old puppy found in permafrost - The Canberra Times - December 4th, 2019
- The Sun joins Boris Johnsons gruelling 16-hour day on the campaign trail - The Sun - December 4th, 2019
- Is it a dog or is it a wolf? 18,000-year-old frozen puppy leaves scientists baffled - CNN - November 28th, 2019
- 18,000-year-old frozen puppy discovered in Siberia - WPTV.com - November 28th, 2019
- Squeaky Curtain divides Europes mice in East and West - Big Think - November 28th, 2019
- Discover more about you with 50% off AncestryDNA's Genetic Ethnicity Test - Android Central - November 28th, 2019
- Kuno will soon be India's next lion sanctuary after Gujarat's Gir - Quartz India - November 28th, 2019
- Alex Blackwell leaves the game having led a cricket revolution - The Guardian - November 28th, 2019
- Genetics linked to same-sex behavior, but there is no 'gay gene,' huge study indicates - Denton Daily - November 28th, 2019
- Indigenous livestock breeding: Deja Moo Bringing the cows home - The Indian Express - November 28th, 2019
- Bedbug invasion: Why the itch-inducing pests are making a big comeback in a building near you - Ottawa Citizen - November 28th, 2019
- Expert offers insights into addiction in Greenwich presentation - CT Insider - November 28th, 2019
- In Search of Galpagos Short-eared Owls on Floreana Island - Island Conservation - Island Conservation News - November 28th, 2019
- A Brief History of Wheat - Resilience - November 28th, 2019
- Losing Nemo: Clownfish 'cannot adapt to climate change' due to their specific mating habits, scientists say - The Telegraph - November 26th, 2019
- Men and women need different treatments for mental illness, expert says - ISRAEL21c - November 26th, 2019
- SBC Pres. JD Greear says he'll refer to trans individuals by their preferred pronouns - The Christian Post - November 26th, 2019
- Kuno, India's second home for the Asiatic lion, is ready - Mongabay-India - November 26th, 2019
- Seattle Genetics Announces Health Canada Approval of ADCETRIS (Brentuximab Vedotin) in Combination with Chemotherapy in Frontline CD30-Expressing... - November 25th, 2019
- Drug combination mutes sensitivity to noise in autism mice - Spectrum - November 25th, 2019
- Assault Case Adjourned for Nationalist Party Founder - DiscoverEstevan.com - November 25th, 2019
- Ancestry Websites Great for Finding Relatives and Suspects - Governing - November 25th, 2019
- Couple overcomes infertility and 50 percent chance of baby having cystic fibrosis - Asheboro Courier Tribune - November 23rd, 2019
- Meet Mister Weasley - the rescue rooster who started life as a hen - Cork Beo - November 23rd, 2019
- The Relationship Between Humor and Depression - Psychology Today - November 23rd, 2019
- Fertility Specialists of Texas Expands Access to High-Quality Treatment for Thousands of Infertile Couples in Fort Worth - PR Web - November 23rd, 2019
- City of Hope to lead national research aimed at improving testing/treatment for devastating cancer-causing syndrome - Business Wire - November 23rd, 2019
- Global Male Infertility Treatment Market: Development History, Current Analysis and Estimated Forecast to 2025 - Market Research Reporting - November 23rd, 2019
- Some gorillas have developed WEBBED FEET and other harmful mutations due to inbreeding - Stock Daily Dish - November 23rd, 2019
- Science Talk - Men's Health Awareness Month: 12 months of progress into male cancer research at the ICR - The Institute of Cancer Research - November 21st, 2019
- Leadership in the genes of guppies - SciTech Europa - November 21st, 2019
- Fissured tongue: Causes and treatment - Medical News Today - November 21st, 2019
- Couple Overcomes Infertility And 50% Chance Of Baby Having Cystic Fibrosis - WFMYNews2.com - November 21st, 2019
- Scientists discover "just one drink" is more accurate than they thought - Inverse - November 21st, 2019
- Changes in animal communication - NDSU The Spectrum - November 21st, 2019
- What's being done to close the research gap when it comes to men's and women's cardiac health - The Loop - November 21st, 2019
- Why this orthopaedic surgeon insists women should 'sit like a man' - Sydney Morning Herald - November 21st, 2019
- Battle of the sexes - Australian Antarctic Division - November 20th, 2019
- Sex in the city: when dad's not dad - The Naked Scientists - November 20th, 2019
- A Rare Genetic Disorder The Blood ' Milky ' White of these Siblings - X Herald - November 20th, 2019
- A Weird Battle of the Sexes is Happening Between Weed and Hemp - Weedmaps News - November 19th, 2019
- Male Infertility: From diagnosis to treatment - ETHealthworld.com - November 19th, 2019
- Rename Breast-Cancer Syndrome to Help Save Lives - UroToday - November 19th, 2019
- Section 377A constitutional challenge: Expert evidence reveal sexual orientation cannot be changed at will, lawyers argue - The Online Citizen - November 19th, 2019
- Henry Cavill Breaks Down His 'The Witcher' Workout Routine - menshealth.com - November 19th, 2019
- Video Captures Australian Woman Braving Brushfire To Save Injured Koala - KFI AM 640 - November 19th, 2019
- A Rare Genetic Disorder Turned These Siblings' Blood 'Milky' White - Livescience.com - November 18th, 2019
- Transgender people who agree with using terms 'men' and 'women' too afraid to speak out, tribunal hears - The Telegraph - November 18th, 2019
- Biosecurity, boars and benchmarking in Pig Progress 9 - Pig Progress - November 18th, 2019
- 2 the Outdoors: Saving a species - WGRZ.com - November 18th, 2019
- Fertility startup Mojo wants to take the trial and error out of IVF - TechCrunch - November 18th, 2019
- Breaking Down The Invitae Short (Podcast Transcript) - Seeking Alpha - November 18th, 2019
- Cleveland Clinic doctor leads effort to reduce health disparities among black men - freshwatercleveland - November 18th, 2019
- Everything Will Wade said ahead of LSU-UMBC - 247Sports - November 18th, 2019
- Scientists Cracked the Case of Why Octopuses of the Same Species Can Look Totally Different - SciTechDaily - November 18th, 2019
- Is sexual orientation genetic? Yes and no, an extensive study finds - Haaretz - November 16th, 2019
- Whos the daddy? Difficult to say in Victorian times - The Guardian - November 16th, 2019
- The American Heart Association's Annual Conference Comes to Philly This Weekend - Philadelphia magazine - November 16th, 2019
- Gene targets for obesity and wildfire research: News from the College | Imperial News - Imperial College London - November 16th, 2019
- The Tasmanian tiger is thought to have gone extinct in 1936, but mysterious sightings suggest the creature might still be out there - INSIDER - November 16th, 2019
- 'Siya got hit in the mouth at school and was bleeding... I just remember him bouncing guys and carrying on' - RugbyPass - November 16th, 2019
- Cyclops and the Summers: The X-Men Family Tree, Explained | CBR - CBR - Comic Book Resources - November 16th, 2019
- The Role of Apolipoprotein E on the Age of Ischemic Stroke Onset and Stroke Outcome - Neurology Advisor - November 14th, 2019
- Genetic study reveals the family secrets of people in the 1800s - New Scientist News - November 14th, 2019
- Ankylosing Spondylitis Not Linked to Axial Psoriatic Arthritis - Pharmacy Times - November 14th, 2019
- Tips on finding female ancestors - The County - November 14th, 2019
- After half a century, Salem soccer referee still can't take his eyes off the game - Salem Reporter - November 14th, 2019
- Stars of the Future draws in quality entries - FG Insight - November 12th, 2019
- She sent 23andMe her DNA. They told her she's intersex. - Newsday - November 12th, 2019
- Genetic genealogy can help solve cold cases. It can also accuse the wrong person. - PBS NewsHour - November 12th, 2019
- HudsonAlpha genetic testing initiative lets Alabamians know of their cancer risk - Yellowhammer News - November 12th, 2019
- Waking Up To My Whiteness - The Black Wall Street Times - November 12th, 2019
- New Study Claims to Pinpoint Exact Location where Human Life Began - The Vintage News - November 12th, 2019