Evolution and war: The ‘deep roots’ theory of human violence – Genetic Literacy Project
Posted: July 8, 2017 at 1:40 pm
The world learned the details of the Islamic States systemic rape and slavery of women through shocking stories told to the New York Times in 2015.Our collective outrage also showed how war has changed. Rape, torture and slavery are considered beyond taboo; they are criminalized even in war. This archaic behavior is not supposed to happen in our modern world.
But thats a pretty recent development. Systemic rape used to go hand in hand with war as women, resources and landswere assimilated into the victors communities. The victorious menhad more children, more land and more power. Some researchers have argued that this is proof of the deep roots theory of war: Human males fight each other for reproductive advantage, proving that war is an evolutionary advantageous behavior.
But this theory has been hard to prove. In fact, studies of human groups and other primates have added to the evidence both for and against the controversial idea that humans were made for war, evolutionarily speaking. A January 2015study indicates that societies dont actually benefit from head-to-head action, though other forms of violence do pay off.
Harvard evolutionary biologists Luke Glowaki and Richard Wrangham studied the Nyangatom people of East Africa. The group are polygamous shepherds who raise small livestock and can have multiple wives. At times, the Nyangatom go to war with other groups. But there is a another pervasive and nearly constant form of violence in the group. Young riders make raids on nearby camps with the goal of stealing cattle. Glowaki and Wrangham asked if either or both of these types of violence was beneficial to the men who engaged in them. They measured by counting the the number of wives and kids they had.
This study is one of many that has heightened thedebate over how muchwar has had an impact on a warriors evolutionary success. At least in this society,sneaking around after dark and stealing cows may have beenmore consequential. Robert Sapolosky at the Wall Street Journal explained:
By contrast, lots of battle raidingopen-field, daytime combat with hundreds of participantsdid not serve as a predictor of elevated reproductive success, probably because such fighting carried a nontrivial chance of winding up dead. In other words, in this society, being a warrior on steroids did not predict reproductive success; being a low-down sneaky varmint of a cattle rustler did.
But researchers only discovered this by looking at the elders in the community. Stealthy animal raiding did lead to better outcomes but decades later. In Nyangatom culture, most of the stolen livestock goes to fathers and other paternal relatives rather than being kept by the young men who stole them. The male heads of families made marriage decisions for their younger relatives. So, while it this kind of violence makes a difference, the payoff is quite delayed. The researchers speculated the cattle-rustling effect would be stronger in a group where the raiders got to keep the livestock they stole and incentives were strengthened.
Other studies also point to the idea that inter-group warfare might not be beneficial, but intra-group violence is. Chimpanzee tribes, for example dont often go to war with other tribes. Instead the most common types of violence involve a group of males ganging up on one individual male. This often happens when conditions are crowded or there were increased numbers of males in the tribe. And the researchers found that chimps participation in violence happened outside of the spheres of human influence, meaning violence was not a behavior the chimpanzees learned from us.
But other evidence suggests that humans likely didnt participate in war as we know it until relatively recently. A 2013 survey of killings in 21 groups (foragers rather than shepherds) found that group warfare was rare compared to homicide. John Horgan categorized the evidence at Scientific American:
Some other points of interest: 96 percent of the killers were male. No surprise there. But some readers may be surprised that only two out of 148 killings stemmed from a fight over resources, such as a hunting ground, water hole or fruit tree. Nine episodes of lethal aggression involved husbands killing wives; three involved execution of an individual in a group by other members of the group; seven involved execution of outsiders, such as colonizers or missionaries. Most of the killings stemmed from what Fry and Soderberg categorize as miscellaneous personal disputes, involving jealousy, theft, insults and so on. The most common specific cause of deadly violenceinvolving either single or multiple perpetratorswas revenge for a previous attack.So it maybe that a proclivity for violence and an innate sense of revenge that perpetuates war, rather than war itself.
Another factor to consider is that while our common ancestors lived in groups like these thousands of years ago, almost no one does anymore. In fact, finding these undisturbed cultures is hard to do. Having more cows doesnt carry the same appeal it once did. Its unlikely stealing your neighbors TV for your uncle will fetch you a better bride. Some scientists worry that if we accept the idea that violence was a beneficial tool for our ancestors, it somehow overturns the societal progress that has moved us beyond the rape and pillage culture to something still imperfect, but largely more peaceful.
This is the biggest struggle with the deep roots theory of human violence. Just because something garnered an advantage thousands of years ago doesnt make it okay today. Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker, who has written a book on human violence, said in the Boston Globe:
romantics worry that if violence is a Darwinian adaptation, that must mean that it is good, or that its futile to work for peace, because humans have an innate thirst for blood that has to be periodically slaked. Needless to say, I think all this is profoundly wrongheaded.
Meredith Knight is a contributor to the human genetics section for Genetic Literacy Project and a freelance science and health writer in Austin, Texas. Follow her @meremereknight.
Read the original here:
Evolution and war: The 'deep roots' theory of human violence - Genetic Literacy Project
- Male roundworms are picky when choosing a mate, new research finds - Phys.org - March 12th, 2024
- Male fertility is declining. Here's what the latest research shows as to why - Yahoo Eurosport UK - March 12th, 2024
- Protein integral to sperm development and male fertility identified - EurekAlert - February 23rd, 2024
- The Y Chromosome Is Vanishing. A New Sex Gene May Be The Future of Men. - ScienceAlert - February 23rd, 2024
- Embracing the Bald: The Journey of Acceptance and the Battle Against Male Pattern Baldness - BNN Breaking - February 23rd, 2024
- Fruit flies give further insight into evolution of male genitalia driven by sexual selection - EurekAlert - February 5th, 2024
- Massive genetic study estimates the chance of dying from prostate cancer - Medical Xpress - January 28th, 2024
- Lean Gene Reviews (USA) Does This Weight Loss Supplement Work? LeanGene Ingredients, Price, Where to Buy? - Outlook India - April 8th, 2023
- The biggest shock was not having a uterus the film about intersex beauty queen Sharon-Rose Khumalo - The Guardian - March 23rd, 2023
- Male Definition & Meaning | Dictionary.com - January 25th, 2023
- Male Genitalia Pictures, Anatomy & Diagram | Body Maps - Healthline - January 25th, 2023
- 15 Alpha Male Traits Characteristics of Real Alpha Males - January 25th, 2023
- The 15 Best Sex Toys for Men, According to Experts - SELF - January 25th, 2023
- Diabetes is increasing in younger population, finds study: Doctors share early signs that might help in early medical intervention - Times of India - January 25th, 2023
- Sexual dimorphism - Wikipedia - December 28th, 2022
- Why Do Men Go Bald: Male Baldness Causes, Treatment, Prevention - December 28th, 2022
- African Americans - Wikipedia - December 28th, 2022
- Talking Glossary of Genetic Terms | NHGRI - Genome - December 12th, 2022
- Risk Factors for Breast Cancer in Men - American Cancer Society - December 12th, 2022
- We have the killers DNA, we just need a name: Genetic game changer offers hope for near-unsolvable Ontario cold cases - Toronto Star - December 12th, 2022
- Hair loss - Symptoms and causes - Mayo Clinic - November 26th, 2022
- Cell Size and Scale - University of Utah - November 26th, 2022
- We created the world's first donkey embryo using IVF in a bid to save species from extinction - The Conversation - November 18th, 2022
- Male infertility - Diagnosis and treatment - Mayo Clinic - October 16th, 2022
- Dangerous Male Sex Pills - CBS News - October 16th, 2022
- Drone (bee) - Wikipedia - October 16th, 2022
- Prestigious award advances OHSU research on impact of drug use over generations - OHSU News - October 16th, 2022
- Breast Cancer Awareness Month: The importance of getting to know your lemons - Bothell-Kenmore Reporter - October 16th, 2022
- Identification of hub genes and candidate herbal treatment in obesity through integrated bioinformatic analysis and reverse network pharmacology |... - October 16th, 2022
- Behind this Nobel prize is a very human story: theres a bit of Neanderthal in all of us - The Guardian - October 16th, 2022
- Column One: Why this UCLA professor is studying female animals to gain insights into women's health - Los Angeles Times - October 16th, 2022
- Books wrap: Simone Kaho on her new poetry collection and PTSD; a conversation with Richard Wolfe; and more - New Zealand Herald - October 16th, 2022
- The 2016 WHO Classification of Tumours of the Urinary System and Male ... - October 8th, 2022
- How to Tell If a Squirrel Is Male or Female | Sciencing - October 8th, 2022
- The Genetic Drivers Of Longevity In Mice, Humans And Worms - Science 2.0 - October 8th, 2022
- A Guide To The Best Fertility Supplements And Vitamins For Men - Forbes - October 8th, 2022
- Early Signs Of Male Plant And Female Plant-How To Identify The Difference? - The Island Now - October 8th, 2022
- Why Not All 'House of the Dragon' Mixed Race Targaryens Are Blonde - Newsweek - October 8th, 2022
- Study on the interaction preference between CYCD subclass and CDK family members at the poplar genome level | Scientific Reports - Nature.com - October 8th, 2022
- Calcium-Channel Blocker and Adenosine Modulator Use and Risk of Hospitalization in Bipolar Disorder - Psychiatric Times - October 8th, 2022
- Israel, A Pioneer In Agriculture Of The Future - I24NEWS - i24NEWS - October 8th, 2022
- Results: Limousin society's 50th anniversary show and sale - Agriland - October 8th, 2022
- Drug resistance and population structure of Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax in the Peruvian Amazon | Scientific Reports - Nature.com - October 8th, 2022
- Do Supplements Help Hair Growth? We Asked An Expert - SheFinds - October 8th, 2022
- Genomic imprinting - Wikipedia - September 30th, 2022
- BRCA beyond breast cancer: links to prostate, pancreatic, other tumors - The Columbus Dispatch - September 30th, 2022
- Severe COVID-19Related Outcomes Found Worse in Men With RA - Medscape - September 30th, 2022
- Let the Bees Tell You. On the Holy Bible (For Beekeepers) of Buckfast Abbey - Literary Hub - September 30th, 2022
- Genetics | Ohio State Medical Center - September 5th, 2022
- Regular exercise may help women live longer, regardless of their genes - Medical News Today - September 5th, 2022
- Habsburg Jaw: The Horrific Consequences of 'Royal Inbreeding' in Europe - TheTealMango - September 5th, 2022
- Alpha Beast XL Reviews (USA & Canada): Is It Legitimate Or Scammer? Shocking Ingredients Alert! - Deccan Herald - September 5th, 2022
- Men More Prone to Cancer Than Women, But Why? - HealthDay News - August 11th, 2022
- For Some Dolphins, the Key to Mating is Rolling with a Tight, Noisy Crew - Scientific American - August 11th, 2022
- Sister's Liver, Mother's Kidney Helps Save Uttarakhand Man's Life - NDTV - August 11th, 2022
- Role of genetic testing in in-vitro fertilization - Express Healthcare - August 11th, 2022
- Protective effect of apolipoprotein E epsilon 3 on sporadic Alzheimer's disease in the Chinese population: a meta-analysis | Scientific Reports -... - August 11th, 2022
- PRC1-mediated epigenetic programming is required to generate the ovarian reserve - Nature.com - August 11th, 2022
- Ashton Kutcher and Autoimmune Disease Vasculitis - Healthline - August 11th, 2022
- ROCKET PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations (form 10-Q) - Marketscreener.com - August 11th, 2022
- Meet the Algae That Went from Male/Female to Hermaphroditic - The Scientist - August 3rd, 2022
- The Sex Appeal of Symmetric Songs | TS Digest | The Scientist - The Scientist - August 3rd, 2022
- Asexual Reproduction: Species Reproducing on Their Own are Susceptible to Dangerous Genetic Mutations - Nature World News - August 3rd, 2022
- Viewpoint: Why genetic engineering of livestock is compatible with the sustainable and human treatment of animals - Genetic Literacy Project - August 3rd, 2022
- Why Do We Get Old, and Can Aging Be Reversed? - Quanta Magazine - August 3rd, 2022
- New Feminist Considerations of Masculinity, Reviewed - The New Yorker - August 3rd, 2022
- Family at 'breaking point' amid difficulties caring for son with rare genetic disorder - The Mirror - August 3rd, 2022
- There are valid reasons so many Nebraska kids have spent their summers detasseling corn - Scottsbluff Star Herald - August 3rd, 2022
- Prehistoric roots of 'cold sore' virus traced through ancient herpes DNA - EurekAlert - August 3rd, 2022
- Funny Papers Again Column | Idiotologies vs The Review and Research Posse - King City Rustler - August 3rd, 2022
- 10 US Parks Where You Can Watch Wildlife In Its Natural Habitat - TheTravel - August 3rd, 2022
- Men Missing Y Chromosome Have High Heart Disease Risk Best Life - Best Life - July 26th, 2022
- Going to the Beach? Planning a Hike? Be Prepared: Men Will Be Much Hungrier! - Neuroscience News - July 26th, 2022
- THE BALANCED LIFE | Use common sense when digesting wellness advice | - The Voice of Pelham - July 26th, 2022
- Ecostani | Despite concerns, the Cheetah project is worth pursuing - Hindustan Times - July 26th, 2022
- To what extent human beings are morally responsible for the actions they take as a result of their innate and acquired influences - Teen Ink - July 26th, 2022
- How Fast Does Hair Grow? Know These Easy-Peasy Tips to Grow your Tresses - TheTealMango - July 26th, 2022
- BETTER KNOW A PREY-GO-NEESH: Up Close and Personal With Your New Condor Neighbors - Lost Coast Outpost - July 26th, 2022
- From the 'Burgh to the Gulf: Lions relocated in zoo breeding program - TribLIVE - July 26th, 2022
- Long Non-Coding RNAs ANRIL and HOTAIR Upregulation is Associated with | IJGM - Dove Medical Press - July 26th, 2022