Row over controversial stem-cell procedure flares up again
Posted: January 31, 2014 at 8:44 am
Nicolo' Minerbi / LUZphoto / eyevine
Mauro Ferrari, who heads the Institute for Academic Medicine at the Houston Methodist Hospital in Texas, is the Italian government's nominee to chair a committee on the controversial Stamina Foundation.
Top scientists in Italy have called on the health minister Beatrice Lorenzin to reconsider the composition of the new scientific advisory committee she has proposed to assess a controversial stem-cell therapy offered by the Stamina Foundation.
Their move follows a renewed media frenzy around the affair, prompted by statements made to the press and television by the committees proposed president, Mauro Ferrari, shortly after he was nominated on 28 December.
The Stamina therapy, which has not been scientifically proven to be effective in a clinical trial, involves extracting mesenchymal stem cells from bone marrow of a patient, manipulating them and then reinjecting them into the same patients blood or spinal fluid. Stamina, based in Brescia, has already treated more than 80 patients for a wide range of serious diseases.
Stamina's practices have been widely criticized by experts both in Italy and outside, and the first government-appointed scientific committee to rule on Stamina prepared a detailed report describing the Stamina protocol as without a scientific basis, ineffective and dangerous. However, a regional court declared that committee unlawfully biased on 4 December. But after that committee's report was leaked to the press on 20 December (see 'Leaked files slam stem-cell therapy'), many families of patients who claim to have been damaged by the therapy announced that they had brought charges for damages against Stamina and its president Davide Vannoni. Both have denied any wrongdoing.
In response to the court findings, minister Lorenzin nominated Ferrari to chair a new committee. Ferrari, who heads the Institute for Academic Medicine at the Houston Methodist Hospital in Texas, told journalists that he was neither for nor against the Stamina method.
However on the 22 January episode of a widely viewed television show, Le iene, Ferrari said he thought Stamina offered Italy the opportunity to take a world lead in bringing experimental therapies into the clinic. He also referred to Stamina as the first important case for regenerative medicine here in Italy, a statement that has incensed some Italian researchers.
Michele de Luca, a stem-cell biologist from the University of Modena and Reggio Emilia says that Ferrari's assertions were an insult to the many scientists in Italy working on translating stem-cell research into new clinical applications. In particular, De Luca's own group was the first in the world to cure a form of blindness with a stem-cell therapy they developed, he points out.
In a letter dated 26 January, which was seen by Nature, four influential clinical scientists say that they were extremely worried by Ferrari's televised statements. The signatories were Silvio Garattini, head of the Mario Negri Institute for Pharmacological Research in Milan; Giuseppe Remuzzi, head of the Mario Negri Institute in Bergamo; Gianluca Vago, rector of the University of Milan; and Alberto Zangrillo, vice-rector for clinical activities at the University Vita-Salute San Raffaele in Milan.
Read the original here:
Row over controversial stem-cell procedure flares up again
- Eli and Edythe Broad Center of Regeneration Medicine and ... - October 30th, 2015
- Molecular & Cellular Medicine - October 29th, 2015
- Sickle cell anemia Treatments and drugs - Mayo Clinic - October 29th, 2015
- How are stem cells used in medicine today? - HowStuffWorks - October 29th, 2015
- Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity An Open Access ... - October 29th, 2015
- Department of Regenerative Medicine and Cell Biology - October 29th, 2015
- Sickle Cell Anemia: MedlinePlus - National Library of Medicine - October 29th, 2015
- Personalized RegenerativeMedicine : Dr David Steenblock - October 29th, 2015
- Cell Therapy and Regenerative Medicine - October 29th, 2015
- The Power of Stem Cells | California's Stem Cell Agency - October 29th, 2015
- Herbal medicine | Cancer Research UK - October 29th, 2015
- UR Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine Institute (SCRMI) - October 29th, 2015
- Penn Medicine News: Genetically Modified "Serial Killer" T ... - October 29th, 2015
- Beta cell regeneration - Center for Regenerative Medicine ... - October 29th, 2015
- The Stem Cell Theory of Cancer - Stanford Medicine Center - October 29th, 2015
- What is a cell? - Genetics Home Reference - October 16th, 2015
- Cell Therapy & Regenerative Medicine - University of Utah ... - October 13th, 2015
- Sickle Cell Anemia: Learn About SCD Symptoms and Treatment - September 26th, 2015
- Research - Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine ... - September 26th, 2015
- Sickle Cell Disease (Sickle Cell Anemia ... - MedicineNet - September 26th, 2015
- T Cell Therapy (CTL019) | The Children's Hospital of ... - September 15th, 2015
- Knoepfler Lab Stem Cell Blog | Building innovative ... - September 10th, 2015
- Cell culture - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - September 6th, 2015
- What are the potential uses of human stem cells and the ... - August 17th, 2015
- One type of airway cell can regenerate another lung cell type - April 13th, 2015
- Limber Lungs: One Type of Airway Cell Can Regenerate Another Lung Cell Type - April 13th, 2015
- Regenestem Network Announces Plans to Attend the 23rd Annual World Congress on Anti-Aging Medicine May 7-9, 2015 - April 6th, 2015
- 'Open' stem cell chromosomes reveal new possibilities for diabetes - April 3rd, 2015
- Key mechanism identified in tumor-cell proliferation in pediatric bone cancers - April 3rd, 2015
- UCI team gets $5 million to create stem cell treatment for Huntington's disease - March 28th, 2015
- Sungduan: Growth factors - March 28th, 2015
- Cleveland Clinic Researchers First to Demonstrate Significant Blocking of Opioid Tolerance With Mesenchymal Stem Cell ... - March 25th, 2015
- Johns Hopkins Medicine, based in Baltimore, Maryland - March 23rd, 2015
- stem cell medicine Jakarta tangerang serpong bsd bintaro - Video - March 21st, 2015
- Global Stem Cells Group to Hold Practical Adipose-Derived Stem Cell Harvesting, Isolation and Re-integration Training ... - March 20th, 2015
- Boston Stem Cell Biotech Start-up Asymmetrex Will Present Essential Technologies for Stem Cell Medical Engineering at ... - March 18th, 2015
- A Single-Cell Breakthrough: newly developed technology dissects properties of single stem cells - March 18th, 2015
- BrainStorm Cell Therapeutics to Present at 3rd Annual Regen Med Investor Day on March 25 in New York - March 18th, 2015
- Global Stem Cells Group to Participate in the 25th Argentine Congress of Aesthetic Medicine in Buenos Aires April 9-10 ... - March 17th, 2015
- Boosting A Natural Protection Against Alzheimer's Disease - March 13th, 2015
- Media portray unrealistic timelines for stem cell therapies - March 12th, 2015
- Stem cells lurking in tumors can resist treatment - March 12th, 2015
- Building custom blood cells to battle sickle cell disease - March 11th, 2015
- Johns Hopkins researchers engineer custom blood cells - March 10th, 2015
- Targazyme Inc. Receives Orphan Drug Designation to TZ101 for Use With Regulatory T Cells to Prevent & Reduce the ... - March 10th, 2015
- Mast cell - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - March 9th, 2015
- Achieving gender equality in science, engineering and medicine - March 9th, 2015
- Seven strategies to advance women in science - March 9th, 2015
- British biotech firm sets crowdfunding record with heart drug - March 9th, 2015
- A good night's sleep keeps your stem cells young - March 9th, 2015
- Howe's recovery shows stem-cell advances - March 1st, 2015
- Translational Regenerative Medicine: Market Prospects 2015-2025 - February 28th, 2015
- Stem cellrecruiting hydrogels based on self-assembling peptides for tissue regeneration - February 25th, 2015
- Sertoli cell - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - February 17th, 2015
- Global Stem Cells Group Announces Alliance with Regenerative Technology - February 11th, 2015
- Biotech firm Cell Therapy claims crowdfunding record with heart drug - February 10th, 2015
- Two UC San Diego Scientists Receive Stem Cell Technology Grants - February 3rd, 2015
- Regenestem Network and Gilberto Hernandez Falcon, M.D. Open Stem Cell Clinic in Yucatan - January 31st, 2015
- Global Stem Cells Group and Regenestem Network Announce Launch of New Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine Clinic in ... - January 29th, 2015
- Asymmetrex Scheduled to Present Unique Perspectives in Stem Cell Biology and Recent Advances in Technologies for Adult ... - January 29th, 2015
- Gordie Howe's stem cell therapy raises concerns among medical experts - January 29th, 2015
- Gordie Howe's stem cell therapy raises concerns among experts - January 29th, 2015
- BioTime Announces Issuance of 14 New Patents in the Fields of Regenerative Medicine, Stem Cell Technology, and Cancer ... - January 27th, 2015
- Keeping the Kraken asleep - January 27th, 2015
- Helmholtz International Fellow Award for Prof. Amanda Fisher from London - January 27th, 2015
- Regenestem Network, a division of Global Stem Cells Group, Announces Launch of New Stem Cells and Regenerative ... - January 22nd, 2015
- Scientists announce revolutionary culturing technique for liver and pancreas - January 22nd, 2015
- New Type of Cell Found to Repair Lung Injury in Mice - January 18th, 2015
- Stem cells derived from amniotic tissues have immunosuppressive properties - January 16th, 2015
- Global Stem Cells Group to Move Headquarters to Larger Miami Lakes Office Complex - January 14th, 2015
- Peter S. Kim Named the Virginia and D.K. Ludwig Professor of Biochemistry at Stanford - January 13th, 2015
- Renowned professor's book addresses stem cell biology & regenerative medicine - January 13th, 2015
- Circadian rhythms regulate skin stem cell metabolism and expansion, study finds - January 7th, 2015
- Cord Blood Banking Leader, Cryo-Cell International, Continues to Support the Advancement of Regenerative Medicine - January 6th, 2015
- Scientists Develop Pioneering Method to Define Stages of Stem Cell Reprogramming - January 6th, 2015
- Pioneering method developed to define stages of stem cell reprogramming - January 6th, 2015
- The Irvine Stem Cell Treatment Center Announces Adult Stem Cell Public Seminars in Orange County, California - January 5th, 2015
- Ten years in, California's stem cell program is getting a reboot - January 4th, 2015
- Two-thirds of cancer cases are "bad luck," study says - January 1st, 2015
- 'Bad Luck' of Random Mutations Plays Predominant Role in Cancer, Study Shows - January 1st, 2015