Enthusiasm for personalized medicine is premature …
Posted: August 9, 2015 at 5:46 pm
August 5, 2015
The increasing national focus on personalized or 'precision' medicine is misguided, distracting from broader investments to reduce health inequities and address the social factors that affect population health, two leading public health scholars argue in the New England Journal of Medicine.
"There is now broad consensus that health differences between groups and within groups are not driven by clinical care, but by social-structural factors that shape our lives," write Sandro Galea, MD, DrPH, dean of the Boston University School of Public Health, and Ronald Bayer, PhD, professor of Sociomedical Sciences and co-director of the Center for the History and Ethics of Public Health at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. "Yet seemingly willfully blind to this evidence, the United States continues to spend its health dollars overwhelmingly on clinical care.
"It is therefore not surprising that even as we far outpace all other countries in spending on health, we have poorer health indicators than many countries, some of them far less wealthy than ours."
Bayer and Galea say that while investments in precision medicine may ultimately "open new vistas of science" and make contributions to "a narrow set of conditions that are primarily genetically determined," enthusiasm about the promise of this research is premature. Leaders of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) have praised President Barack Obama's recent initiative to devote $215 million to personalized medicine, an emerging practice of medicine that uses an individual's genetic profile to guide decisions in regard to the diagnosis and treatment of disease.
"Without minimizing the possible gains to clinical care from greater realization of precision medicine's promise, we worry that an unstinting focus on precision medicine by trusted spokespeople for health is a mistakeand a distraction from the goal of producing a healthier population," they write.
Arguing that clinical intervention will not remedy pressing health problems that arise from environmental conditions and inequities in income and resources, they cite a 2013 report by the National Research Council and the Institute of Medicine that found Americans fared worse in terms of heart disease, birth outcomes, life expectancy and other indicators than their counterparts in other high-income countries. The report concluded that "decades of research have documented that health is determined by far more than health care."
They call for greater public investments in "broad, cross-sectional efforts" to minimize the socioeconomic and racial disparities in the U.S. that contribute to poor health.
Bayer and Galea say the NIH's most recent Estimates of Funding for Various Research, Condition and Disease Categories report shows that total support for research areas including the words 'gene,' 'genome' or 'genetic' was about 50 percent higher than funding for areas including the word 'prevention.' And investment in public health infrastructure, including local health departments, lags substantially behind that of other high-income countries.
In explaining why they felt compelled to speak out, Galea and Bayer said they are wary that that specialized medicine will push larger public health initiatives aside.
Excerpt from:
Enthusiasm for personalized medicine is premature ...
- Personalized medicine: Precise genomic solutions for disease - May 7th, 2016
- U.S. Public Opinion about Personalized Medicine Survey ... - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine - NIH News in Health, December 2013 - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine News -- ScienceDaily - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine: Redefining Cancer and Its Treatment - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine: How the Human Genome Era Will Usher ... - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized medicine - Bio-Medicine - latest biology and ... - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine Conference | Medical Events | 2016 ... - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized medicine - ScienceDaily - May 7th, 2016
- Center for Personalized Medicine | Roswell Park Cancer ... - May 7th, 2016
- Precision Medicine - Food and Drug Administration - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine | Cancer Genetics Inc. - May 7th, 2016
- value of personalized medicine - PhRMA - May 7th, 2016
- Personalized Medicine | Breast Cancer New York & LA - May 7th, 2016
- About | Partners HealthCare Personalized Medicine - October 21st, 2015
- Welcome to the Indiana Institute for Personalized Medicine - October 5th, 2015
- Personalized Genetic Medicine Conference | Partners ... - October 4th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine - National Institutes of Health (NIH) - October 4th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine: The Future is Now | FDA Voice - October 4th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine - Oregon Health & Science University - October 4th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine Conferences | Europe | Worldwide ... - September 5th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine and Cancer Companion Diagnostics - August 6th, 2015
- Pharmacogenomic Testing Services | Personalized Medicine ... - August 1st, 2015
- The Koch Institute: Personalized Medicine - July 5th, 2015
- SELECTBIO - Personalized Medicine and its Impact in the Clinic - July 5th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine, Targeted Therapeutics and Companion ... - June 28th, 2015
- The Promise of Personalized Medicine - Vanderbilt Magazine - June 27th, 2015
- Conquering Cancer: Personalized Medicine Is the Future ... - June 21st, 2015
- Personalized medicine could mean big business for D.C ... - June 1st, 2015
- Personalized medicine and pharmacogenomics - Mayo Clinic - May 28th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine - Food and Drug Administration - May 23rd, 2015
- Personalized Medicine - Information and Resources - May 23rd, 2015
- Personalized Medicine Coalition precision medicine - May 19th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine - Articles - May 19th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine Bulletin Personalized Medicine ... - May 19th, 2015
- Mendoza Foresight: Personalized Medicine - Video - May 4th, 2015
- Populations to People: The Practice of Personalized Medicine - Video - May 4th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine Video - Video - May 1st, 2015
- Mihai Diamandopol at Bucharest Forum Healthcare 2015 - Video - April 29th, 2015
- Oana Cuzino at Bucharest Forum Healthcare 2015 - Video - April 24th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine: Targeting the Tumor - Nevena Damjanov, MD - Video - April 24th, 2015
- Dr. Goldkorn - Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) & the Future of Personalized Medicine in Oncology - Video - April 23rd, 2015
- Personalized Medicine: Genome Mapping - Video - April 23rd, 2015
- Heart chip beats towards better drug screening, personalized medicine - Video - April 17th, 2015
- Accelerating the Promise of Personalized Medicine - Video - April 12th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine for Melanoma Aims at Keeping the Immune System Awake - Video - April 12th, 2015
- Bringing Genomics Home Vancouver 2015 - Brad Popovich - Video - April 11th, 2015
- Dr Decker PGx Case Study - Video - April 11th, 2015
- Dr Vuppalanchi Pharmacogenomic in Gastroenterology and Heptology - Video - April 11th, 2015
- Dr Decker PGx Ordering and Clinical Implementation - Video - April 11th, 2015
- Dr Schneider IU Percision Tx Initiative - Video - April 4th, 2015
- CEN4GEN Institute for Genomics and Molecular Diagnostics - Video - April 2nd, 2015
- Pharmacogenomics: Personalized Medicine in Private Practice - Video - April 2nd, 2015
- Pharmacogenomics at Mayo Clinic with MedxPrime with Lee - Video - March 31st, 2015
- Orthopedic Rehabilitation Treatment using Personalized Medicine | Russ Scala - Video - March 29th, 2015
- Dr. Prashant Yadav speaking on the topic Personalized Medicine - Video - March 29th, 2015
- Dr Kreutz Personalized Medicine a Case Study - Video - March 29th, 2015
- Why Angelina Jolies Surgery Isnt for Everyone - Video - March 28th, 2015
- Research with Fruit Flies? - Video - March 22nd, 2015
- Personalized Medicine on the Today Show - Video - March 22nd, 2015
- Horizon Discovery: The Power of Personalized Medicine - Video - March 22nd, 2015
- My Conversation with Ralph Snyderman, Father of Personalized Medicine (Pt 2) - Video - March 21st, 2015
- My Conversation with Ralph Snyderman, Father of Personalized Medicine (Pt 1) - Video - March 21st, 2015
- Horizon Discovery: The Impact of Horizons Technology Platform (short version) - Video - March 20th, 2015
- Melbourne Conversations - Personalised Medicine: Me and My Genome - Video - March 15th, 2015
- Putting personalized medicine to the test - Video - March 15th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine Risk Assessment FInal Master - Video - March 14th, 2015
- Medicine in the Digital Age | RiceX on edX | About Video - Video - March 14th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine-Risk Assessment with Final Revisions for Final Review - TEMP Link - Video - March 11th, 2015
- Scientist: Personalized Medicine -Susan Baxter Career Girls Role Model - Video - March 11th, 2015
- Obamas State of the Union Address Personalized Medicine - Video - March 8th, 2015
- Center of Innovation in Personalized Medicine (CIPM) - Video - March 6th, 2015
- European policies in Personalized Medicine. Isabel de la Mata - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Personalized Medicine MedXPrime DNA testing Safe drugs - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Q&A - Perspectives on Targeting and Implications for Personalized Medicine - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Aren't Lifestyle & Personalized Medicine inspired by Ayurveda? - Video - March 5th, 2015
- LSI Public Talks on Personalized Medicine - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Biotechnology & human genome sequencing. Javier Garca - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Dr. Oz MedXPrime Personalized Medicine DNA testing - Video - March 5th, 2015
- Genomics of Personalized Medicine - Video - March 5th, 2015