Has the Era of Gene Therapy Finally Arrived? – Scientific American (blog)
Posted: September 6, 2017 at 9:40 pm
In 1990, geneticist William French Anderson injectedcells with altered genes into a four-year-old girl with severe immunodeficiency disorder. This was the first sanctioned test of gene therapy, in which genetic material is used to treat or prevent disease.
If were lucky, Anderson told The Chicago Tribune, with this little girl weve opened the door for genetic engineering to attack major killers and cripplers, particularly AIDS, cancer and heart disease.
Gene therapy has never fulfilled these grand hopes. In the decades since Andersons experiment, thousands of clinical trials of gene therapies have been carried out. But the first gene therapy was only approved for sale in the U.S. this week. The Food and Drug Administration announced its approval of Kymriah, a gene therapy produced by Novartis for a form of childhood leukemia. A few gene therapies have previously become available in China and Europe.
An FDA press release emphasizes the historic nature of the approval. Were entering a new frontier in medical innovation with the ability to reprogram a patients own cells to attack a deadly cancer, FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb says.
As I have noted in previousposts (see Further Reading), the hype provoked by genetic research has always outrun the reality. Gene-therapy proponents have long predicted that it will eliminate diseases such as cystic fibrosis and early-onset breast cancer, which are traceable to a defective gene, as well as disorders with more complex genetic causes.Enthusiasts also envisioned genetically engineered "designer babies" who would grow up to be smarter than Nobel laureates and more athletic than Olympians.
Gene therapy turned out to be extremely difficult, because it can trigger unpredictable, fatal responses from the body's immune system.The National Institutes of Health warnsthat gene therapy can have very serious health risks, such as toxicity, inflammation, and cancer.
Kymriah is a case in point. The FDA press release warns that Kymriah can cause life-threatening immune reactions and neurological events, as well as serious infections, low blood pressure (hypotension), acute kidney injury, fever, and decreased oxygen (hypoxia). According to The New York Times, the FDA is requiring that hospitals and doctors be specially trained and certified to administer [Kymriah], and that they stock a certain drug needed to quell severe reactions.
Kymriah illustrates another problem with gene therapy: high cost. Novartis is charging $475,000 for Kymriah. As a recent Reuters article notes, over the past five years two gene therapies have been approved for sale in Europe, one for a rare blood disease and the other for the bubble-boy immunodeficiency disorder. The therapies cost $1 million and $700,000, respectively. So far, the companies that make the therapies have achieved a total of three sales.
As journalist Horace Freeland Judson points out in this excellent 2006 overview, The Glimmering Promise of Gene Therapy, biology and economics have conspired against gene therapy. Judsonnotes that most individual diseases caused by single-gene defectsthe kind that seem most likely to be cured by gene therapyare rare. (Sickle-cell anemia and some other hemoglobin disorders are among the few exceptions.)
Judson adds that because different diseases have different genetic mechanisms and affect different types of tissue, each presents a new set of research problems to be solved almost from scratch. As the millions burned away, it became clear that even with success, the cost per patient cured would continue to be enormous. And success had shown itself to be always glimmering and shifting just beyond reach.
The advent of CRISPR, a powerful gene-editing technique, has inspired hopes that gene therapy might finally fulfillexpectations. Researchers recently employed CRISPRin human embryos to counteract a mutation that causes heart disease. Potentially, The New York Times reported last month, the method could apply to any of more than 10,000 conditions caused by specific inherited mutations.
CRISPR has also renewed concerns about the ethics of engineering people with enhanced physical and mental traits. These concerns are grossly premature. As Science noted recently, CRISPR poses some of the same risks as other gene therapies. The methodstill has a long way to go before it can be used safely and effectively to repairnot just disruptgenes in people.And in fact questions have now been raised about the CRISPR research on embryos mentioned above.
Some day, applied genetics might live up to its hype, but that day is far from arriving.
Further Reading:
Could Olympians Be Tweaking Their Genes?
Have researchers really discovered any genes for behavior?
My Problem with Taboo Behavioral Genetics? The Research Stinks!
Hype of Feel-Good Gene Makes Me Feel Bad.
New York TimesHypes "Infidelity Gene."
Quest for Intelligence Genes Churns out More Dubious Results.
Warrior Gene Makes Me Mad.
Should Research on Race and IQ Be Banned?
Read more:
Has the Era of Gene Therapy Finally Arrived? - Scientific American (blog)
- This Pitt program is leveling up the gene therapy workforce in Pittsburgh - University of Pittsburgh - March 12th, 2024
- Opinion | Banning Gain-of-Function Research Would Do Far More Harm Than Good - Medpage Today - March 12th, 2024
- The Biggest Challenges Facing Broader Adoption of Novel Cell and Gene Therapies - Pharmaceutical Executive - March 12th, 2024
- Research and development areas of focus - Bristol Myers Squibb - March 4th, 2024
- Overcoming the challenges of gene therapy - Drug Discovery News - March 4th, 2024
- Breakthrough Gene Therapy for LHON: Vision Restoration in Focus at Medical Conference - BNN Breaking - March 4th, 2024
- Revolutionizing Healthcare: Global Gene Therapy Market Surges to US$ 3.44 Billion by 2022 As Revealed In Ne... - WhaTech - March 4th, 2024
- Looking to the future of clinical trials: Gene therapy, precision medicine, and the ongoing quest for rare disease solutions - pharmaphorum - March 4th, 2024
- Complement system response to AAV vector gene therapy - EurekAlert - February 23rd, 2024
- 10 gene therapy companies you should know about - Labiotech.eu - February 23rd, 2024
- Fetal surgery expert Tippi MacKenzie shifts to in-utero gene therapy - STAT - February 23rd, 2024
- Rejuvenate Bio Announces Gene Therapy-Mediated Partial Reprogramming Extends Lifespan and Reverses Age ... - Business Wire - February 23rd, 2024
- Combatting HIV using gene therapy - Drug Target Review - February 23rd, 2024
- Expanding the Horizons of Cell and Gene Therapy - RegMedNet - February 23rd, 2024
- Global Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products CDMO Market Analysis Report 2024-2030: : Increasing Investment and ... - Yahoo Finance UK - February 23rd, 2024
- 2023 gene therapy research STAR Grant winners announced - Pacific Biosciences - February 13th, 2024
- Lifetime Cost of DEB Gene Therapy Could Be $15-$22 Million - Medscape - February 13th, 2024
- 5 Things Youll Learn in Frederick Community Colleges New Cell and Gene Therapy Essentials Certificate ... - BioBuzz - February 13th, 2024
- Regenxbios investigational gene therapy shows promise in Hunter syndrome - PMLiVE - February 13th, 2024
- Topical Gene Therapy Effective in Treating Debilitating Eye Condition - InventUM - University of Miami - February 13th, 2024
- Bayer Says First Patient Randomized In Askbio Phase II Gene Therapy Trial - XM - February 13th, 2024
- Top 3 grants in regenerative medicine: January 2024 - RegMedNet - February 13th, 2024
- Realistic Expectations, Limitations With Gene Therapy for Parkinson Disease: Ignacio Mata, PhD - Neurology Live - February 5th, 2024
- Gene-Based Therapy May Slow Development of Life-Threatening Heart Condition - NYU Langone Health - February 5th, 2024
- After Promising Early Efficacy, Eli Lilly Eager to Study Hearing Loss Gene Therapy in More Children - precisionmedicineonline.com - February 5th, 2024
- Gene therapy hailed as medical magic wand for hereditary swelling disorder - The Guardian - February 5th, 2024
- France Approves Gene Therapy Clinical Trial to Treat Hearing Loss in Children - The Hearing Review - February 5th, 2024
- Early Trial Success for Inherited Deafness Gene-Therapy - RegMedNet - February 5th, 2024
- Can gene therapy be the key to restoring hearing loss? - Labiotech.eu - February 5th, 2024
- Jaguar Gene Therapy Announces FDA Clearance of IND to Study JAG201 in a Genetic Form of Autism Spectrum ... - Business Wire - February 5th, 2024
- FDA inspection clears Abeona's gene therapy BLA By Investing.com - Investing.com - February 5th, 2024
- Hearing Restored in Deaf Children in Gene Therapy Clinical Trial - Securities.io - February 5th, 2024
- Experimental gene therapy allows kids with inherited deafness to hear - The Associated Press - January 28th, 2024
- Children with genetic deafness have hearing restored with gene therapy: Study - ABC News - January 28th, 2024
- Positive Phase 1/2 Clinical Trial Data for an Investigational Gene Therapy for Genetic Hearing Loss to be Presented at ... - Investors | Eli Lilly and... - January 28th, 2024
- UChicago Medicine among the first in the country to offer newly approved sickle cell gene therapies - UChicago Medicine - January 28th, 2024
- Gene Therapy Allows an 11-Year-Old Boy to Hear for the First Time - The New York Times - January 28th, 2024
- Gene therapy restores hearing in children with hereditary deafness - EurekAlert - January 28th, 2024
- Experimental gene therapy helps treat kids with inherited hearing loss - CBS News - January 28th, 2024
- Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Performs First in U.S. Gene Therapy Procedure to Treat Genetic Hearing Loss - PR Newswire - January 28th, 2024
- Gene Therapy Brings Hearing to Kids With Congenital Deafness - U.S. News & World Report - January 28th, 2024
- Gene Therapy Restores Hearing in Small Trial for Kids With Hereditary Deafness - Technology Networks - January 28th, 2024
- Cell Therapies on Ice: Seven Trends in Cryopreservation To Enable Cell and Gene Therapy Research - Technology Networks - January 28th, 2024
- Gene Therapy Brings Hearing to Kids With Congenital Deafness - HealthDay - January 28th, 2024
- Gene therapies restore hearing in several kids with inherited deafness - Livescience.com - January 28th, 2024
- 11-Year-Old Boy Hears For First Time Ever Thanks To Gene Therapy Breakthrough - IFLScience - January 28th, 2024
- Innovative Gene Therapy Restores Hearing In Deaf Child, Offering Potential Cure - Study Finds - January 28th, 2024
- Sound of Success, Gene Therapy Breakthrough Grants Hearing to Deaf Children in China-Harvard Study - Hoodline - January 28th, 2024
- Perspectives in FTD Research Webinar: Gene Therapy for FTD -- What Do I Need to Know? | AFTD - AFTD - January 20th, 2024
- UK leads the way in cell and gene therapy - Research Professional News - January 20th, 2024
- Charles River's (CRL) New Launch to Boost Gene Therapy Programs - Yahoo Finance - January 20th, 2024
- UK maintains status as an attractive destination for advanced therapy clinical trials - BioPharma-Reporter.com - January 20th, 2024
- Understanding the impact of AI on the advancement of gene therapy development - pharmaphorum - January 20th, 2024
- Gene therapy TSHA-102 delivered to 1st child in REVEAL trial - Rett Syndrome News - January 20th, 2024
- AAV Vectors in Gene Therapy Market is Predicted to Observe Skyrocketed Growth During the Study Period (2019-2032 ... - PR Newswire - January 20th, 2024
- Family pins hopes on gene therapy - The Recorder and Times - January 20th, 2024
- Arbor, 4DMT partner on new gene therapies in ALS, other diseases - ALS News Today - January 11th, 2024
- The year of gene therapy? FDA's Marks calls for solutions to regulatory, manufacturing challenges - BioWorld Online - January 11th, 2024
- Gene Therapy Approvals Expected to Ramp Up in 2024 Amid Manufacturing, Cost Challenges - BioSpace - January 11th, 2024
- Turning On Gene Therapy with the pA Regulator - RegMedNet - January 11th, 2024
- Revolutionizing Healthcare: Gene Therapy Market Projected to Reach USD 46.5 billion by 2030 at a 22. - PharmiWeb.com - January 11th, 2024
- Regeneron CEO Reveals the Game-Changing Potential of Gene Therapy in Biotech! - BioTecNika - January 11th, 2024
- Bayer's AskBio checks off another early win for gene therapy platform with Parkinson's safety data - FierceBiotech - January 11th, 2024
- Are Rare Brain Diseases the Next Commercial Frontier for Gene Therapy? - MedCity News - January 3rd, 2024
- Novartis, Voyager Ink Up-to-$1.3B Expansion of Neuro Gene Therapy Collaboration - Genetic Engineering & Biotechnology News - January 3rd, 2024
- Novel switch turns genes on/off on cue, a promising step toward safer gene therapy - Phys.org - January 3rd, 2024
- Which Therapeutic Areas Experts Think Will Gain Traction In 2024 - Clinical Leader - January 3rd, 2024
- Voyager Therapeutics and Novartis Announce Major Licensing Deal in Gene Therapy Field - Medriva - January 3rd, 2024
- We Are About to Enter the Golden Age of Gene Therapy - Inverse - January 3rd, 2024
- Revolutionizing Gene Therapy: Baylor Researchers Develop RNA-Based Switch for Therapeutic Protein Control - BNN Breaking - January 3rd, 2024
- Casgevy and Lyfgenia: Two Gene Therapies Approved for Sickle Cell Disease - Yale Medicine - December 25th, 2023
- Top story: Family connects with researchers behind Canavan gene therapy - UMass Medical School - December 25th, 2023
- Excision Bio Seeks to Suppress HIV Replication With CRISPR Gene Therapy - AJMC.com Managed Markets Network - December 25th, 2023
- Hemgenix Gene Therapy Shows Long-Term Efficacy, Safety in Hemophilia B Patients - Managed Healthcare Executive - December 25th, 2023
- The missing piece of the puzzle - EUobserver - December 25th, 2023
- Brace yourselves for these trends in clinical research in 2024 - Labiotech.eu - December 25th, 2023
- RegMedNet's 2023 remix: top content of the year - RegMedNet - December 25th, 2023
- BU Researchers Helped Develop the First FDA-Approved Gene Therapies to Treat Sickle Cell Disease - Boston University - December 16th, 2023
- Research discovers that mice possess a natural gene therapy system - Phys.org - December 16th, 2023
- Cell- and gene-therapy hub bound for Lake Success; New York to invest up to $150 million - Newsday - December 16th, 2023